Hi @jenandesign, first of all, welcome in the plugincafe community.

No worry at all, since it's your first post, but I would like to point you about few rules in order to properly ask questions in this forum for future ones (I've set up this one).

• How to Post Questions (Especially the tagging system).
• Q&A New Functionality.

With that's said. Regarding your question. I get it to work (a bit hacky) but it's working.
When C4D render a scene, actually the whole scene is cloned in memory and then it renders this one. (It allow a user to still work on C4D while the other scene is rendering).
So this render scene is read-only, you shouldn't modify at anytime anything in this scene, or you can screw up the render.
Moreover in a shaderData, in order to optimize memory, only relevant information (aka polygon, UV) are copied. So you are losing your UserData.
This means you have to find another way to find your effector.
So the way I find to achieve what you want is to get the document from the object passed to the shader(the rendered document).
Then in this document, I search for an effector called "Plain" (Not the most robust way but it's working).

Then here the final code I put on the python color channel of a sketch and toon

import c4d

def main():
    doc = op.GetDocument()
    effector = doc.SearchObject("Plain")
    if not effector: return c4d.Vector()
    
    eff =  c4d.modules.mograph.C4D_Falloff()
    if not eff: return c4d.Vector()
    eff.InitFalloff(bc=effector.GetData())

    eff.SetMg(effector.GetMg())
    eff.SetMode(effector[c4d.FALLOFF_MODE])

     # World position currently sampled
    value = eff.Sample(wPnt, False)
    return c4d.Vector(value)

And the attached scene where a plain effector drives a mograph effector and the sketch and toon shader.
0_1542626486830_SketchAndToon.c4d

If you have any questions, please let me know!
Cheers,
Maxime!

Hi @merkvilson first of all pip and Niklas localimport module is completely two different things.

• pip is a python module manager (similar to package manager in unix). This means once it's installed to a python binary, it will be able to manage other modules, download them, install them with all their dependencies and update them and so on.
• localimport is a python module that let you manage import in a local way while in Cinema 4D by default is global. For more information please read how the import function works in python.
  Meaning if you add a module named xyz to the sys.path from your plugin A and from plugin B you try to import another module named xyz, it will load the one from plugin A (the first one register).

Now how to install pip?

1. Downloads https://bootstrap.pypa.io/get-pip.py.
2. Downloads the c4dpy version matching your Cinema 4D version. (Already included in R21)
3. Moves c4dpy and get-pip.py in the Cinema 4D folder.
4. Opens a shell to the Cinema 4D folder:
   • Window: Type cmd in the top path and press Enter.
   • Mac: Open a new shell, then with cd navigate to your Cinema 4D folder. (You can drag and drop the path).
5. Runs this command line c4dpy get-pip.py. This will execute the get-pip script which will, download and install the pip module.
6. Now you can start to play with pip c4dpy -m pip install numpy. c4dpy allow to runs any module with the -m argument see c4dpy commandline. in this case I asked to pip to download and install numpy but any other 3rd party compatible with pip can be downloaded and used.

With that's said we do not provide support for 3rd party modules, so if it does not work with Cinema 4D Python environment, we can't help you.

Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi @kisaf,

MCOMMAND_MIRROR is indeed a bit special because when you click on the Apply button from the GUI, it does send a message to some c4d elements, then these elements read MDATA_MIRROR_VALUE, MDATA_MIRROR_SYSTEM and MDATA_MIRROR_PLANE calculates values for MDATA_MIRROR_POINT and MDATA_MIRROR_VECTOR and then call the SendModelingCommand. Unfortunately, there is no way for you to send this message, and the best way to do it is to recalculate the stuff as bellow.

import c4d


def main():
    # Checks if selected object is valid
    if op is None:
        raise ValueError("op is none, please select one object.")

    # Defines some general settings, take care MDATA_MIRROR_VALUE, MDATA_MIRROR_SYSTEM and MDATA_MIRROR_PLANE
    settings = c4d.BaseContainer()
    settings[c4d.MDATA_MIRROR_DUPLICATE] = True
    settings[c4d.MDATA_MIRROR_SELECTIONS] = True
    settings[c4d.MDATA_MIRROR_ONPLANE] = True
    settings[c4d.MDATA_MIRROR_WELD] = True
    settings[c4d.MDATA_MIRROR_TOLERANCE] = 0.01

    # Corresponds to MDATA_MIRROR_VALUE, MDATA_MIRROR_SYSTEM and MDATA_MIRROR_PLANE
    value = 1000.0
    system = 0 # 0 = Object, 1 = World
    plane = 1 # 0 = XY, 1 = ZY, 2 = XZ

    if not 0 <= system < 2:
        raise ValueError("System can only be 0 or 1")

    # Buffer position vector
    pos = c4d.Vector()

    # Calculates Local (Object) coordinates
    if system == 0:
        globalMatrix = op.GetMg()
        if plane == 0:
            pos = globalMatrix.v3
        elif plane == 1:
            pos = globalMatrix.v1
        elif plane == 2:
            pos = globalMatrix.v2

        settings[c4d.MDATA_MIRROR_POINT] = globalMatrix.off + pos * value
        settings[c4d.MDATA_MIRROR_VECTOR] = pos

    # Calculates World coordinates
    elif system == 1:
        if plane == 0:
            pos = c4d.Vector(0.0, 0.0, 1.0)
        elif plane == 1:
            pos = c4d.Vector(1.0, 0.0, 0.0)
        elif plane == 2:
            pos = c4d.Vector(0.0, 1.0, 0.0)

        settings[c4d.MDATA_MIRROR_POINT] = pos * value
        settings[c4d.MDATA_MIRROR_VECTOR] = pos

    # Send the Modeling Operation
    res = c4d.utils.SendModelingCommand(c4d.MCOMMAND_MIRROR,
                                        [op],
                                        c4d.MODELINGCOMMANDMODE_ALL,
                                        settings,
                                        doc)

    c4d.EventAdd()


if __name__ == "__main__":
    main()

Hope it solves your issue, if you have any question, please let me know.
Cheers,
Maxime.

So regarding your script why it crashes, it's simply because you make an infinite loop with this code since you add each time something more to iterate.

for idx in newPos:
    newPos.append(GlobalToLocal(oldObject, idx))

Just to make it cleaner I've called objA and objB.
Then the needed steps are:

1. Get World Position from points of objB.
2. Convert these World Position in the local space of objA.

So as you may be already aware regarding our Matrix Fundamentals where is how to achieve both operations.

• Local Position to World Position corresponds to the obj global matrix where the position is locals to multiplied by the local position.
• World Position to Local Position corresponds to the inverse obj global matrix where the position will be locals multiplied by the world position.

Finally, before providing with the solution I would like to remind you to please always execute your code in the main function. The main reason is that if you transform your script as a button in the Dialog, every code that is in the global scope of your script is executed for each redraw of the Cinema 4D GUI (which is pretty intensive!). Moreover please always check for objects, if they exist or not try to adopt a defensive programming style in order to avoid any issues.

import c4d

def main():
    # Declares object variables
    ObjA = doc.SearchObject("A")
    ObjB = doc.SearchObject("B")

    # Checks if objects are found
    if ObjA is None or ObjB is None:
        raise ValueError("Can't found a and b object")

    # Checks if they are polygon object
    if not isinstance(ObjA, c4d.PolygonObject) or not isinstance(ObjB, c4d.PolygonObject):
        raise TypeError("Objects are not PolygonObject")

    # Checks Point count is the same for both obj
    allPtsObjA = ObjA.GetAllPoints()
    allPtsObjB = ObjB.GetAllPoints()
    if len(allPtsObjA) != len(allPtsObjB):
        raise ValueError("Object does not get the same pount count")

    # Retrieves all points of B in World Position, by multipling each local position of ObjB.GetAllPoints() by ObjB.GetMg()
    allPtsObjBWorld = [pt * ObjB.GetMg() for pt in allPtsObjB]

    # Retrieves All points of B from World to Local Position of ObjA, by multipling each world position of ObjB by the inverse objA.GetMg()
    allPtsObjANewLocal = [pt * ~ObjA.GetMg() for pt in allPtsObjBWorld]
    
    # Sets New points position
    ObjA.SetAllPoints(allPtsObjANewLocal)
    ObjA.Message(c4d.MSG_UPDATE)
    
    # Updates Cinema 4D
    c4d.EventAdd()

# Execute main()
if __name__=='__main__':
    main()

If you have any questions, please let me know.
Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi @mikeudin, due to how our Classic Python API is built deepcopy does not work since our python objects only store pointer to our internal C++ object and not directly to other Python objects, so deepcopy fail in this regards since, the deepcopy operation, free and try to recreate these data, which is not possible since they are not PyObject but real C++ object but copy.copy does works, but since it's a shallow copy operation it only works for one level (e.g. a dict of dict of DescID will fail).

For more information about the difference please read Shallow vs Deep Copying of Python Objects.

However here a couple methods to copy a dict.

import copy
dict1 = {'1':dId_one,'2':dId_two}
dict2 =  copy.copy(dict1)

dict1 = {'1':dId_one,'2':dId_two}
dict2 =  dict1.copy()

dict1 = {'1':dId_one,'2':dId_two}
dict2 =  dict(dict1)

Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi @mike, first of all I would like to remind you to read and use the Q&A functionnality.

Regarding your question, here is an example of a basic GeDialog, which make use to SetFloat to define a range.

import c4d

class MonDlg( c4d.gui.GeDialog):
    idSlider = 1000
    idButton = 1001

    # Create the Layout
    def CreateLayout(self):
        self.AddEditSlider(self.idSlider, c4d.BFH_SCALE|c4d.BFV_SCALE, initw=100, inith=20)
        self.AddButton(self.idButton, c4d.BFH_SCALE|c4d.BFV_SCALE, initw=100, inith=20,name = 'Get Value')	
        return True

    # Called after CreateLayout
    def InitValues(self):
        self.SetFloat(self.idSlider, 0.25, min=0.0, max=1.0, step=0.01, min2=0.0, max2=0.0)
        return True

    # Called for each interaction from a widget
    def Command(self, id, msg):
        if id == self.idButton:
            print self.GetFloat(self.idSlider)
        
        return True

def main():
    dlg = MonDlg()
    dlg.Open(c4d.DLG_TYPE_MODAL)

if __name__=='__main__':
    main()

If you have any questions please let me know.
Cheers,
Maxime!

Hi @chuanzhen actually the problem interested me and I took some personal time on my weekend to do some tests.

I did 2 test scenes, which was a cube with 163970 points driven by 3 joints
With your original source code 0.53 fps
optimize python: 1.09 fps (x2.05)
C++: 19.36 fps (x36.52)

And the other one was the same cube but driven by 11 joints.
With your original source code 0.37 fps
optimize python: 0.64 fps (x1.73)
C++: 12.08 (x32.65)

So here is the optimized python code. As you can see I try to avoid as much as possible doing operation in the nested loop.

class newskin(plugins.ObjectData):
 
    lasttagdirty = None   #for weight change update
    jointdir = None       #for joint change update
    cachedir = None       #for other bindmesh check
 
    def CheckDirty(self, op, doc):
        #check first run
        if op[c4d.NEWSKINTAG] is None:
            op.SetDirty(c4d.DIRTYFLAGS_DATA)
            return
 
        #check weight change
        if op[c4d.NEWSKINTAG].GetDirty(c4d.DIRTYFLAGS_DATA) != self.lasttagdirty:
            op.SetDirty(c4d.DIRTYFLAGS_DATA)
            return
 
        #check matrix change
        checktime = op[c4d.NEWSKINTAG].GetJointCount()
        cdirty = 0
 
        for i in xrange(checktime):
            cdirty += op[c4d.NEWSKINTAG].GetJoint(i).GetDirty(c4d.DIRTYFLAGS_MATRIX)
 
        if cdirty != self.jointdir or self.cachedir != op[c4d.NEWSKINCHECK].GetDirty(c4d.DIRTYFLAGS_CACHE):
            op.SetDirty(c4d.DIRTYFLAGS_DATA)
            return
 
        return
 
   
    def ModifyObject(self, mod, doc, op, op_mg, mod_mg, lod, flags, thread):
 
        if mod[c4d.NEWSKINTAG] is None or mod[c4d.NEWSKINCHECK] is None:
            return True
 
        tag = mod[c4d.NEWSKINTAG]
        self.lasttagdirty = tag.GetDirty(c4d.DIRTYFLAGS_DATA)  #get current weight tag dirty
        self.cachedir = mod[c4d.NEWSKINCHECK].GetDirty(c4d.DIRTYFLAGS_CACHE)    #get bindmesh check
        plist = [pos * op_mg for pos in op.GetAllPoints()]
        pcount = op.GetPointCount()  
        jcount = tag.GetJointCount()
        self.jointdir = 0
 
        for m in xrange(jcount):
            joint = tag.GetJoint(m)
            self.jointdir += joint.GetDirty(c4d.DIRTYFLAGS_MATRIX)   #all joint current matrix dirtycount
 
        temp = c4d.Vector()
        for n in xrange(pcount):    #n:point index  
            temp %= temp
 
            for m in xrange(jcount):
                joint = tag.GetJoint(m)
                weight = tag.GetWeight(m, n)
 
                if not weight :
                    continue  
 
                cjmg = joint.GetMg()
                jdict = tag.GetJointRestState(m)
                jmg = jdict["m_bMg"]
                jmi = jdict["m_bMi"]
 
                temp += weight * cjmg * jmi * plist[n]  #defrmer global pos
            plist[n] = temp
       
        plist = [~op_mg * pos for pos in plist]
        op.SetAllPoints(plist)
        op.Message(c4d.MSG_UPDATE)
 
        return True

And here the C++ version (compatible R20 only). It uses paralellFor, not sure it's really worth didn't do proper profiling about it but I wanted to try them. Moreover please do not consider my C++ code has fully optimized since you could probably improve it depending on the situation.

#include "c4d_symbols.h"
#include "main.h"
#include "c4d_objectdata.h"
#include "lib_ca.h"

// Local resources
#include "oskinmodifier.h"
#include "maxon/parallelfor.h"
#include "maxon/basearray.h"

/**A unique plugin ID. You must obtain this from http://www.plugincafe.com. Use this ID to create new instances of this object.*/
static const Int32 ID_OBJECTDATA_SKINMODIFIER = 1000002;

class SkinModifier : public ObjectData
{
	INSTANCEOF(SkinModifier, ObjectData)

public:
	static NodeData* Alloc() { return NewObj(SkinModifier) iferr_ignore("SkinModifier plugin not instanced"); }

	virtual void CheckDirty(BaseObject *op, BaseDocument *doc);
	virtual Bool ModifyObject(BaseObject* mod, BaseDocument* doc, BaseObject* op, const Matrix& op_mg, const Matrix& mod_mg, Float lod, Int32 flags, BaseThread* thread);

private:

	BaseList2D* GetBaseLink(BaseObject* op, DescID id, Int excepted);
	Int lasttagdirty; /// get current weight tag dirty
	Int jointdir;
	Int cachedir;
};

void SkinModifier::CheckDirty(BaseObject *op, BaseDocument *doc)
{
	BaseList2D* t = GetBaseLink(op, DescID(NEWSKINTAG), Tweights);
	BaseList2D* l = GetBaseLink(op, DescID(NEWSKINCHECK), Opolygon);
	if (!t || !l)
		return;

	PointObject* linkOp = static_cast<PointObject*>(l);
	CAWeightTag* tag = static_cast<CAWeightTag*>(t);

	// check first run
	if (!tag)
	{
		op->SetDirty(DIRTYFLAGS::DATA);
		return;
	}

	// check weight change
	if (tag->GetDirty(DIRTYFLAGS::DATA) != lasttagdirty)
	{
		op->SetDirty(DIRTYFLAGS::DATA);
		return;
	}

	// check matrix change
	Int cdirty = 0;
	for (Int i = 0; i < tag->GetJointCount(); i++)
	{
		cdirty += tag->GetJoint(i, tag->GetDocument())->GetDirty(DIRTYFLAGS::MATRIX);
		if (cdirty != jointdir || cachedir != linkOp->GetDirty(DIRTYFLAGS::CACHE))
		{
			op->SetDirty(DIRTYFLAGS::DATA);
			return;
		}
	}

	return;
}

BaseList2D* SkinModifier::GetBaseLink(BaseObject* op, DescID id, Int excepted)
{
	GeData data;
	if (!op->GetParameter(id, data, DESCFLAGS_GET::NONE))
		return nullptr;

	return data.GetLink(op->GetDocument(), excepted);
}


Bool SkinModifier::ModifyObject(BaseObject* mod, BaseDocument* doc, BaseObject* op, const Matrix& op_mg, const Matrix& mod_mg, Float lod, Int32 flags, BaseThread* thread)
{
	if (!mod || !op || !doc || !thread)
		return false;

	BaseList2D* t = GetBaseLink(mod, DescID(NEWSKINTAG), Tweights);
	BaseList2D* l = GetBaseLink(mod, DescID(NEWSKINCHECK), Opolygon);
	if (!t || !l)
		return false;

	PointObject* linkOp = static_cast<PointObject*>(l);
	CAWeightTag* tag = static_cast<CAWeightTag*>(t);

	lasttagdirty = tag->GetDirty(DIRTYFLAGS::DATA);
	cachedir = linkOp->GetDirty(DIRTYFLAGS::CACHE);

	PointObject* pObj = ToPoint(op);
	const Vector * pListR = pObj->GetPointR();
	Vector * pListW = pObj->GetPointW();

	const Int pcount = pObj->GetPointCount();
	const Int jcount = tag->GetJointCount();
	jointdir = 0;

	for (Int i = 0; i < jcount; i++)
	{
		BaseObject* joint = tag->GetJoint(i, doc);
		jointdir += joint->GetDirty(DIRTYFLAGS::MATRIX);
	}


	auto worker = [jcount, op_mg, &pListR, &pListW, &doc, &tag](maxon::Int i)
	{
		Vector temp;
		Vector pos = op_mg * pListR[i];

		for (Int m = 0; m < jcount; m++)
		{
			Vector pos = op_mg * pListR[i];
			BaseObject* joint = tag->GetJoint(m, doc);
			Float weight = tag->GetWeight(m, i);

			if (weight == 0.0)
				continue;

			Matrix cjmg = joint->GetMg();
			JointRestState jrest = tag->GetJointRestState(m);
			Matrix jmg = jrest.m_bMg;
			Matrix jmi = jrest.m_bMi;

			temp += weight * cjmg * jmi * pos;
		}
		pListW[i] = ~op_mg * temp;
	};

	maxon::ParallelFor::Dynamic(0, pcount, worker);

	// Notify Cinema about the internal data update.
	op->Message(MSG_UPDATE);

	return true;
}

Bool RegisterSkinModifier()
{
	return RegisterObjectPlugin(ID_OBJECTDATA_SKINMODIFIER, "C++ oskinmodifier"_s, OBJECT_MODIFIER, SkinModifier::Alloc, "oskinmodifier"_s, nullptr, 0);
}

Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi @FlavioDiniz, first of all, welcome in the plugincafe community!

Don't worry, since it's your first topic, I've set up your topic correctly. But please for your next topics, use the Q&A functionnaly, make sure to also read How to Post Questions.

With that's said you can find the manual about SetDParameter in the C++ docs which will be trigger each time a user changes a value in the description of your tag. And also the C++ manual about GetDDescription.
Here a quick example of the implementation in python

    extensions = ["exr","hdr","jpg","png"]

    # Called by C4D when loading description
    def GetDDescription(self, node, description, flags):
        data = node.GetDataInstance()
        if data is None:
            return False

        # Load the description
        if not description.LoadDescription(node.GetType()):
            return False

        # If there is no description for c4d.TESTSCALE, we create it. Otherwise we override it and set DESC_CYCLE with our extensions list.
        singleID = description.GetSingleDescID()
        paramID = c4d.DescID(c4d.TESTSCALE)
        if singleID is None or paramID.IsPartOf(singleID)[0]:
            bcParam = description.GetParameterI(c4d.TESTSCALE)

            items = c4d.BaseContainer()
            for i, extension in enumerate(self.extensions):
                items.SetString(i, extension)

            bcParam[c4d.DESC_CYCLE] = items

        return (True, flags | c4d.DESCFLAGS_DESC_LOADED)

    # Called when a parameter is Set
    def SetDParameter(self, node, id, t_data, flags):
        if not node:
            return

        # called when the filename is changed. We add the path to our list and we return c4d.DESCFLAGS_PARAM_SET to inform c4d the paramaters is just sets
        if id[0].id == c4d.STRINGTEST:
            self.extensions.append(t_data)
            return (True, flags | c4d.DESCFLAGS_PARAM_SET)

        return False

If you have any questions, please let me know!
Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi @Ashton_FCS_PluginDev, we are glad to see you back in the new plugincafe community!
No worries at all since it's your first post here, but please make sure to read and apply the rules defined on the following topics:

• How to Post Questions.
• Q&A Functionality.

Regarding your issue, you read m_spec, but you never check if there is a bitmashader in it or not. And in your case, there is no, so m_spec is set to None, and you are then trying to access value.
So please always check for None.
Then since you directly read the BITMAPSHADER_FILENAME parameter from this shader, please also consider to check the shader type you retrieve, maybe a user used a noise and not a bitmap.

m_spec = userMat[c4d.MATERIAL_REFLECTION_SHADER]
if not m_spec or m_spec.CheckType(c4d.Xbitmap):
    continue

Finally, as you may already be aware, reflection gets multiple layers. You get some information in this thread, how to deal with it.

If you have any others question, please let me know!
Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi @mike,
No worries at all since, but please make sure to read and apply the rules defined on the following topics:

• Q&A Functionality.

Regarding your question, you can make use of the Shift Priority Tags. You can find more information on the priority in the c4d help.

But C4D also offer the Shift Priority Tag.
Finally, note in some case it can be a limitation of the viewport which not refresh properly while data are correctly set.
And you need to manually refresh the viewport.

Hope it solves your issue, if you have any question please let me know!
Cheers,
Maxime!

Hi @delizade as @Cairyn pointed out you should implement a GeDialog to create a dialog.
The creation of the dialog is done within the CreateLayout method, where you need to call AddEditText to add some text input. The first parameter is an ID(int) that is used to identify the gadget. You are free to choose what you want but they should be unique in your dialog. You can retrieve the value of such input with GetString and the id used on the creation. If you want to know when the value change, you can override the Command method, which is called for each Gadget change with the ID of the gadget.

Find more information about GeDialog in the C++ Manual, don't be afraid, the code is really adaptable to Python but this manual have some context that could help you to understand the whole logic of GeDialog. And finally find some example of GeDialog in the Python Github repository.

Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi @AiMiDi, MSG_DRAGANDROP will be received when the host receive a drag, I didn't tried but I guess only dialog can react to this message. In you case you will need to set the NBIT NBIT_NO_DD like so op.ChangeNBit(c4d.NBIT_NO_DD, c4d.NBITCONTROL_SET).

Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi would it be possible to share you resource file?
Do you override the Message method?

I saw that you use the flag DESCFLAGS_DESC::RECURSIONLOCK is there any reason for that? This prevent further evaluation and may cause the issue.

One things, you can also upload GIF up to 4mb directly in the forum (just drag and drop it).

Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi @Kantronin, I don't have a lot to add Thanks @Cairyn , for more information about the console, please read Python Console.

Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi @Kantronin I don't think there is that much to add but I want to mention that c4d.CallCommand automatically add an undo to the undo stack, while c4d.utils.SendModelingCommand with it's flags arguments can be defined. But you need to start and end the undo with the c4d.utils.SendModelingCommand, so this way you can have multiple SendModelingCommand within an undo.

See basedocument_undo example for undo management.

Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi @InterfaceGuy Unfortually we do not provide support for 3rd party module, even more to old version which had issue with pip.

Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi I did try using the PLUGINFLAG_COMMAND_STICKY Unfortually this does not work as expected, I would need to dig a bit into it to see if there is any workaround to it. I will let you know.

Cheers,
Maxime

Hi sorry I missed your reply.
Effector does not expose any API, so the only way would be to make the all setup in a virtual document, execute it (via ExecutePass) and then copy back the data.
But this is not an easy task since you need to take care of all the dependency of an effector (and there is again no API to help you in this purpose, so it's on you to retrieve all the stuff necessary).

Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi @Ling, the snap popup is a built-in menu, so you can't easily reproduce it however it's possible to build such a kind of menu but not with ShowPopupDialog.

If you want all features you mentioned you will need to create a CommanData plugin (registered with the c4d.PLUGINFLAG_COMMAND_STICKY flags).
Then a c4d.gui.GeDialog opened with the flags DLG_TYPE_ASYNC_POPUPEDIT to have a popup like dialog. To have the ability to dock it, you should use GeDialog.AddGadget with the c4d.DIALOG_PIN flags.
Finally to build the menu, you will need to draw it manually with a GeUserArea.

If you want more detail, please let met know,
Cheers,
Maxime.

Hi @baca, you are right you should remove the OBJECT_INPUT but this imply you need to handle them correctly.

I'm not able to reproduce the delay you mention here my code

    def GetVirtualObjects(self, op, hierarchyhelp):
        orig = op.GetDown()
        if orig is None:
            return None

        dirty = False

        trans = c4d.AliasTrans()
        if not trans or not trans.Init(op.GetDocument()):
            return False
        dic = op.GetAndCheckHierarchyClone(hierarchyhelp, orig, c4d.HIERARCHYCLONEFLAGS_ASPOLY, True, trans)
        trans.Translate(True)
        if not dic["dirty"]:
            return dic["clone"]
        if not dic["clone"]:
            return None

        main = None
        clone = dic["clone"]
        if clone.CheckType(c4d.Onull):
            main = clone
        else:
            main = c4d.BaseObject(c4d.Onull)
            clone.InsertUnder(main)

        orig.Touch()

        return main

Cheers,
Maxime.